Late in their This Old Democracy podcast conversation, Micah Sifry puts an unusual question to Alex Hertel-Fernandez. Suppose the government actually wanted to help people —as workers, parents, patients, consumers, what have you. How would the many and varied demands of a complex society make their way into politics and governance if the political parties meant to serve as the “transmission belt” have lost so many of their ties to non-wealthy people? Hertel-Fernandez is a Columbia University professor, co-director of its Labor Lab and a founder of the Empowering Democracy Initiative. He previously served in the Biden administration’s Department of Labor and White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, and he is very interested in this question!
In a recent essay with colleagues Sam Berger and Sophie Jacobson, he argues that a future pro-democracy administration will need to ask who gains power from its policies, not only who receives their benefits.
🎧 Listen to This Old Democracy on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Youtube and your other favorite podcast platforms.
In his book State Capture, Hertel-Fernandez details how conservative donors, businesses and organizations built networks across the states. They developed policies, cultivated allies in statehouses and understood that a legislative win could make the next win easier to achieve, especially if it structurally weakened the opposition. Perhaps their #1 target in this regard was state policy toward unions and unionized workers.
Right from the start, groups like the American Legislative Exchange Council were really focused on cutting back labor rights and making it harder for unions to organize workers. And that wasn’t a coincidence. I think they accurately saw that cutting back labor rights would weaken a key opponent and make it easier for the allies that they had in government to win elections and change policy.
Weakening organized labor not only reduced workers’ bargaining power; it also reduced their power to influence political party platforms.
Hertel-Fernandez encountered the reverse problem while working in the Biden administration. Policymakers devoted serious attention to whether a program would get benefits to people who needed them. Whether it would help those people organize themselves, and be ready to defend the program if necessary, was rarely discussed.
That question illustrates the focus of the Empowering Democracy Initiative. EDI brings researchers, organizers and people with experience in government together to, in its own words, “understand how to build people power through policy.”
Hertel-Fernandez borrows organizer Ai-jen Poo’s image of three Earths. Earth One is the familiar world of elections and policy fights. Earth Two is the authoritarian capture underway now. Earth Three is the more inclusive democracy one might hope to build. These aren’t successive eras, he says; we’re living in all three at once. That makes restoring the old order not only impossible but also inadequate.
“It’s really about accepting this Earth Two threat that we face and trying to think about policy levers to build the kind of civil society power we need to get to Earth three. Like what kind of worker organizing, tenant organizing, consumer organizing, patient organizing do we need to push back against this threat in Earth Two and get to the Earth three that we want?”
What would one of those policy levers look like? Hertel-Fernandez use the expanded child tax credit, which sent monthly payments to families for six months during Covid, as an example. He asks whether the law could or should also have helped those families organize themselves:
“So, how might you have designed that policy differently if you had put someone from EDI at the table? I think one thing is creating mechanisms for child tax credit recipients to organize collectively together in, say, a parents union, for instance.”
In the Earth Three/EDI version of the expanded child tax credit, organizers could have helped families enroll. A parents’ union could have provided real-time feedback to the Treasury Department as it administered the credit. And when the temporary expansion was about to expire, parents would have a way to make their case together to Congress.
Sifry likes the idea, but – being a party animal – he can’t help but ask: Isn’t this the job of a political party? Hertel-Fernandez agrees that the structural weakness of 21st century American political parties is part of the problem. Once vibrant and locally-focused, American parties today are basically national fundraising machines without thick ties to their voters. Stronger civic organizations might help repair some of those frayed ties, but Sifry wonders whether that is enough given just how alienated people are from both major parties. Not to mention the barriers to entry for new parties.
Hertel-Fernandez doesn’t take the bait. Neither fusion voting nor proportional representation is as yet part of the Empowering Democracy Initiative’s agenda. He does, however, see a reason to make room for organizations—and perhaps parties—that bring together people whose interests don’t follow the familiar partisan divide:
And to really get out of this polarized mess, we need to think about ways of creating more cross-cutting cleavages, whether that’s through new parties that do not fall on the standard left-right spectrum, or new civil society organizations. You know, we are really excited by the effort, for instance, to create a patients union that is being launched right now
If you like listening to alternative visions of how to make government more responsive and inclusive, Hertel-Hernandez makes for a good tour guide of Earth Three. Particularly the Expanded Child Tax Credit thought exercise. And then stick around for Micah’s challenge about whether, if people build power together, our electoral system gives them a way to use it.
Why is this newsletter called The Ticket? The name comes from the phrase “vote the ticket,” which is what political parties urged their supporters to do in the 1800s, when fusion was legal and widely practiced (see here if you don’t know how fusion voting works). Parties printed their own ballots or published them in newspapers that they were aligned with. Then they exhorted their supporters to “vote the ticket” by dropping that ballot or page from the newspaper into the ballot box on Election Day. All such ballots were legitimate, and “fusion” coalitions between major and minor parties were commonplace from Abolition to the turn of the 20th century. But Jim Crow Democrats (in the South) and Gilded Age Republicans (in the North and West) eventually tired of the challenge and disruption that third parties represented, and in state after state fusion voting was outlawed (and coalitions between parties disappeared). But what was banned can be unbanned.
If you’re new to fusion voting and fusion parties, this Democracy Journal piece is a useful starting point.

